Sun Jan. 11 2009 3:20:22 PM
Mel Lastman proud about calling in army to clear snow 10 years ago
The Canadian Press
Members of the Royal Canadian Regiment (from left to right) Pte. Paul Roventa, Master Cpl. Gary Walters, Cpl. Cameron Kerryann, and Pte. Phil Cheung shovel snow in downtown Toronto Friday, Jan.15, 1999. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Kevin Frayer)
TORONTO Ten years after a series of winter storms buried Toronto under more than a metre of snow, former mayor Mel Lastman still takes pride in calling on the military to tackle clogged city streets while large swaths of wintry Canada looked on in wonder.
While the move raised eyebrows nationwide and gave a country that loves to hate Toronto even more ammunition, Lastman looks back on his actions in January, 1999 as absolutely necessary.
"When something like that is happening and there's so much snow and people can't get to work and seniors can't get a bottle of milk at the corner, there's a problem," Lastman said in a recent interview from his Toronto home.
"No mayor has ever called in the army, please understand that."
The former head of the city's transit commission, David Gunn, knew full well Toronto had become the butt of a national joke by having soldiers clear snow from, among other places, bus shelters.
"People made fun of it, but on the other hand we used them," Gunn said.
The first snowy punch arrived during the lunch hour on Jan. 2.
A huge system from the U.S. started making its way through the city, bringing with it snow and a wind chill that hovered around minus 20 C. The winds picked up and visibility was near zero at times. By day's end, there was a whopping 38 centimetres of snow on the ground, crippling the downtown core.
On Jan. 4, Lastman declared a snow emergency, which banned cars from parking on designated snow routes.
Mother Nature wasn't finished.
Over the next several days, Toronto received more snow -- all in smaller increments, but adding to what was already clogging up the streets and rendering the transit system virtually useless.
Lastman's driver took him out to survey the cumulative damage during a Jan. 12 snowfall, when the city was smacked with another 21 cm. Cars were parked on both sides of the narrow side-streets and there were huge ruts down the centre.
"How can an ambulance get through there? How can a fire truck get through there? How can a car get out of there? It's impossible," Lastman said.
Environment Canada was predicting another major snowfall in two days time, so Lastman picked up the phone and asked then defence minister Art Eggleton to get the military involved.
"I said `Art, what kind of equipment do you have, what kind of people have you got available?' And he says `Mel, I don't know, but I'll look."'
Eggleton did just that.
"I listened to him and then I called the commander in Toronto, of Canadian Forces Base Toronto, to find out what their take on it was and how they felt about assisting -- whether this made sense or not," said Eggleton.
"The conclusion was that yes, if... this additional heavy snowfall came there could be an untenable situation in terms of the movement of emergency vehicles."
On Wednesday, Jan. 13, Lastman declared yet another snow emergency and Gunn told Toronto residents who relied on North America's second-largest transit system to stay home.
"You knew that the weekend was going to be just impossible," Gunn recalled.
"The worst thing you can do is tell everyone it's going to be great and then it's a disaster."
Most of the subway system is underground, but for the portions above ground, the snow blocked the third rail line which conducts electricity to the trains. Some 700,000 transit customers were left stranded as subways came to a halt.
That same Wednesday, Lastman announced that the military was sending troops to Toronto.
On Thursday, Jan. 14, a group of 400 soldiers from CFB Petawawa, Ont., driving armoured personnel vehicles known as Bisons and toting an assortment of other heavy machinery rolled into the old Canadian Forces Base Downsview awaiting their assignments.
"I don't think people who have ridiculed this measure have understood that this was an extraordinary circumstance," Eggleton said.
"It had the potential to be as disastrous in a Toronto context as the ice storm would have been for eastern Ontario and western Quebec, but it never turned out to be quite that bad."
Another 26.6 cm of snow would fall that Thursday -- much less than predicted.
By Friday it had ended, and bit by bit the troops helped remove the white mountains from the city's streets.
During the time the troops were in Toronto, 35 people were taken to hospital in the hulking military vehicles that tackled roads that ambulances couldn't.
After time, there wasn't much for the soldiers to do. However, Gunn found a way to make use of them.
"I said, 'Well have them shovel out bus stops and streetcar stops,' and they did and they were great."
Monday came and the transit system was functioning again. People headed back to work, and slowly but surely, the city got back to normal.
There's been nothing quite like it in Toronto since.
The city saw 118 centimetres of snow fall in January, 1999 and the snow clearing tab came in at $70 million that month alone.
Lastman recalls it as one the busiest months he had in office.
"I did the right thing, and I showed too that politicians should be safe rather than sorry," he said.
"You've got to do what's right."
| E-Mail Story |

Caribana 2010
Taste of the Danforth
G20 Special Section











Comments are now closed for this story
January 11, 2009 at 4:48:07 PM
LP4
Wonder what would happen if the City tired to organize neighborhood volunteers to help clearing their own local roads for these extreme circumstances. It would certainly show which area takes pride in their neighborhood. But I imagine City could start to take it for granted and call upon it all the time.
January 11, 2009 at 6:05:51 PM
Diza1
I agree with LP4...using neighbourhood volunteers not only reduces the amount of money the city uses on clearing snow but it also helps neighbourhoods get to know their fellow neighbours and have a sense if camaraderie and solidarity
January 11, 2009 at 6:44:35 PM
RK
maybe unemployed guys would recommend the neighbours to work together on something like this, people have jobs to go to, and we tax payer deserves the army service
January 11, 2009 at 8:01:19 PM
AM77
I agree with RK. Most of us have jobs, children and other things that take us away from clearing snow. It was bad enough last year with all the snow and again this year already. I live beside two neighbours that have snow blowers and not one of them offered to help me with my driveway. Now how neighbourly is that? Let the city do what they want to do and calling in the army was fine. Why should we be laughing. We are tax payers and if the city is in need of help it was put to the right reason.
January 11, 2009 at 8:42:58 PM
LP4
RK,
Many people hold down a job and volunteer regularly. You don't have to be unemployed to do it. I guess that concept is new to you. You are not entitled from the military to shove the snow off your street. The only reason military did it is because Toronto asked nicely.
It's either that or many people don't make it to work.
January 12, 2009 at 10:36:21 PM
Darren
Everyone should do their part, starting from their own sidewalk. Using good tax dollars to it is just a waste of money
January 12, 2009 at 6:46:43 AM
Omar S
I remember this. The "snow emergency" was called January 4th on my 16th birthday. My father went out of way, and out of pocket, to get me a tickets for that day's Leafs game against the Lighting at the Gardens. It would have been my first Leafs game, Wendel Clark was "coming home", despite being on the visitor's bench, and it was one of the very last games played at the Gardens. We couldn't go because of the parking ban. We ended up watching the game at home while we held onto our tickets that had cost my father a small fortune. I still have the unused tickets on my wall and, to this day, have never seen an NHL game live. Thanks, Mel! You "saved the city"! You're my personal hero!
*I'd also like to thank my father,Khader, genuinely, for going out of his way to get me those tickets. It WAS an awesome birthday present!!!
January 12, 2009 at 8:21:44 AM
Brian
10 years later it still cracks me up remembering Lastman called in the military to shoot any snowman on sight!! What a boneheaded move by a mayor who shouldve stayed selling appliances. Who else besides Lastman is "proud" of calling in the army? Noooooobbboooodddddyyyy!!!!!
January 12, 2009 at 9:43:02 AM
JEB
Holy slow news day ... this happened ten years ago!
January 12, 2009 at 9:42:50 AM
Maria (former and VERY proud Montrealer)
As a relatively new Torontonian (born & raised in Montreal), people back home ask me all the time if the army's been called in whenever they hear that Toronto's been hit with snow over 5cm. Hilarious!!!
January 12, 2009 at 9:39:02 AM
Michelle
I, for one, am glad that Mayor Lastman did this - yeah, people can make fun of Toronto, but Lastman was right. What if ambulances, police and fire were unable to do their jobs? I think back to Hurricane Katrina and how long it took the army to get there to save people - it would have been nice if the Mayor of New Orleans had had such foresight as our Mayor Lastman. I would rather look back on this Snow Army Episode with a bit of a chuckle than shake my head in sadness recalling a city-wide disaster that could have been avoided.
Michelle, Mississauga
January 12, 2009 at 9:35:55 AM
ginsugirl
My memories of the Army coming in to TO are mostly of some bored troops, hanging out at my cafe, with one always making a rowdy nuisance of herself (just my luck to get the bad apple). The troops I spoke to saw the whole thing as a big joke.
Some good did come out of the whole fiasco: I found a husband. After two weeks of staying at my boyfriend's house, out of commuting necessity, we realized "hey, this is great! We can actually do this." And here we are, ten years later!
January 12, 2009 at 10:14:08 AM
Steve B
WOW ... now bloggers start to sound like politicians .... lets make this clear 'volunteering' should be left to JUST that, being voluntary... don't try to force it on the other citizens just because some of you are able to do it, there are just as many willing people that simply can't do it due to many other issues, they don't need another 'volunteer or else' law put in place.