A Manitoba judge has ordered a judicial recount after a western municipality’s mayoral race was decided by one vote.
On Friday, Court of King’s Bench Justice Jonathan Woolley ordered a recount in the Rural Municipality of Yellowhead to be held at the Brandon courthouse on Dec. 3. Each party to the recount may be present, the order notes.
The order comes after mayoral candidate Jim Garlick received 375 votes and lost to incumbent Merv Starzyk, who won with 376. Third-place candidate Chantelle Shwaluk received 157 votes.
Garlick, a first-time candidate, applied for the recount on Nov. 4. The rural municipality includes the Town of Shoal Lake and had just over 1,800 residents in the 2021 census, according to Statistics Canada.
“I got a lot of supporters and even non-supporters within the community or RM saying that I should get a recount done,” Garlick told CTV News on Monday.
He said there were 13 spoiled ballots and that “there was a lot of outcry” after the results. Garlick said he will accept the recount’s outcome either way, acknowledging it could widen his margin of loss.
“This way, it’s going to put everybody at rest that it’s all done right. Not saying it wasn’t done right, but this way at least it’s finalized,” he said.

Starzyk, who was first elected mayor in 2018 and has served 37 consecutive years on council, said the application did not come as a surprise.
“I fully expected it, because being one vote difference, it does make you wonder if there was an error made,” he said. “But personally, I have full confidence in the people that work the polls and the senior election officer, but we’ll see what happens on December 3.”
In a statement, a provincial spokesperson said the Municipal Councils and School Boards Elections Act presumes election officials’ counts are accurate. As a result, the act requires the senior election official to request a judicial recount only when there is uncertainty about a tied vote, the spokesperson said.
The spokesperson said a candidate or other voter can also apply for a judicial recount if they believe there were errors in decisions to accept or reject a ballot, in the statement of the vote from a polling station, or in the overall statement of official results.
The statement said the act includes safeguards such as requiring at least two election officials to conduct the count and allowing candidates and their scrutineers to observe it. It said that if no candidate or voter has concerns, there is “no obvious reason to consume judicial resources with an automatic recount.”
Nick Krawetz, deputy executive director of the Association of Manitoba Municipalities, said six of the 135 municipal elections held in October had head of council races decided by fewer than 10 votes.
Besides Yellowhead, the races were in Melita, Minitonas-Bowsman and Minto-Odanah (each by five votes), Mountain (seven votes) and La Broquerie (nine votes).
Court records also indicate that Lewis Weiss, a candidate for reeve in the RM of La Broquerie, has applied for a judicial recount.
CTV News has reached out to Weiss’s lawyer for comment and is awaiting a response.


