Canada

Manitoba’s proposed ban on AI images in real estate draws mixed reaction

Published: 

Manitoba is promising to ban the use of AI images in real estate. CTV's Danton Unger explains.

Among the Manitoba government’s plans for the upcoming year is a promise to ban artificial intelligence images in real estate.

Premier Wab Kinew announced the proposed ban in the government’s Throne Speech Tuesday, calling it an affordability measure for Manitobans.

“When you get taken for a ride and you rent a bunk apartment because you were misled, you’re getting ripped off,” Kinew said, noting consumer protection is a provincial jurisdiction.

Kinew said he briefly met with Realtors on Monday.

“My hope is that this thing gets met completely voluntarily, and we just put the standard out there, and we say we shouldn’t be using AI in photos of apartments and condos and homes,” he said.

Winnipeg real estate photographer and videographer Mike McComb is against the idea.

Winnipeg real estate Winnipeg real estate photographer and videographer Mike McComb says the government’s focus on AI staging is “ridiculous.” McComb says virtual staging can save sellers thousands of dollars, and that there is a right way to use it. (Danton Unger/CTV News Winnipeg)

“I think the government of Manitoba’s got better things to do than worry about virtual staging of photography in real estate places,” he said. “I personally think it’s a ridiculous focus.”

McComb uses artificial intelligence to virtually stage homes, taking his own photos and videos of a space and filling them with AI-generated furniture.

“I would say of the couple hundred listings a year that I do, about 10 per cent of them ask for virtual staging,” he said, calling it a much cheaper alternative to traditional staging.

“It can cost them $2,000 or $3,000 a month for actual staging to take place. That means the whole house has to have furniture in it … It looks great, but it’s expensive to do.”

While he understands the controversy around AI use in real estate, he said there is a right way and a wrong way to use the tool.

An AI application used by McComb shows an original photo (left) next to the same room staged with AI-generated furniture (right). McComb says about 10 per cent of his listings request virtual staging. (Danton Unger/CTV News Winnipeg) An AI application used by McComb shows an original photo (left) next to the same room staged with AI-generated furniture (right). McComb says about 10 per cent of his listings request virtual staging. (Danton Unger/CTV News Winnipeg)

“If a real estate agent ever asked me to get rid of a crack in a wall, or, during drone shots, to get rid of some bad shingles that are on the roof — I wouldn’t take part in that,” he said.

The premier didn’t provide any details about what would or would not be included in the ban.

The Winnipeg Regional Real Estate Board already has a policy in place which governs images.

“Photos can be virtually staged but only in a way that doesn’t misrepresent true physical characteristics or the condition of the property,” a spokesperson for the board told CTV News in an email, noting proper disclosure is required if a listing uses virtual staging.

Winnipeg Realtor Kyle Bazylo supports the idea of an AI ban.

Winnipeg realtor Kyle Bazylo says he supports the proposed ban. He says some listings have changed so much with AI that buyers show up to showings and find the home looks different from the online photos. (Danton Unger/CTV News Winnipeg) Winnipeg Realtor Kyle Bazylo says he supports the proposed ban. He says some listings have changed so much with AI that buyers show up to showings and find the home looks different from the online photos. (Danton Unger/CTV News Winnipeg)

“The problem is people are using it way too much, and they’re totally changing their pictures,” he said. “You’re having people coming to showings and the house is totally different from what they saw in pictures online. You’re just wasting everyone’s time at that point.”

He pointed to a listing that went viral a few months ago showing images of a Winnipeg house with a mountain view, a cartoon skyline of downtown, and a Simpsons-style rendering of the property.

“Even though some people are using it properly, you have too many people abusing it, and I’d rather just have everyone on the same playing field and then go from there,” he said.

The premier said he will share more details about the proposed ban once the legislation has been seen by the house.