The B.C. corporation that owns Shark Club, Moxies and several other Canadian restaurant chains is suing the leaders of a defunct electronic payments company over more than $2.1 million in alleged missing employee tips.
Northland Restaurant Group, Inc. and several affiliated companies filed a notice of civil claim in B.C. Supreme Court last week, alleging that the six defendants—all current or former directors or officers at the payments company XTM—assisted in the company’s breach of trust and knowingly received property that should’ve been held in trust.
The allegations in Northland’s lawsuit have not been proven, and the defendants have not yet filed a response to the claim.
Funds ‘no longer available’
According to the court filing, Northland was XTM’s largest client for its “AnyDay” platform, a payment system that facilitated the distribution of tips and petty cash reimbursements to restaurant employees through prepaid cards and mobile wallets.
The system was supposed to work by allowing Northland and its subsidiaries to transfer funds into separate “custodial accounts” that would be held in trust by XTM and used to fund the prepaid cards and wallets held by employees.
The lawsuit alleges that instead of holding Northland’s funds in separate accounts, XTM placed all of the funds it received in “a single pooled account across approximately 4,000 clients.”
XTM also allegedly made multiple false public representations that there were separate bank accounts held in trust for each of its clients, according to the lawsuit.
The document claims Northland learned of the comingled funds in January of this year. At the same time, it learned that the total amount of client money deposited into the pool was approximately $12 million, that roughly 75 per cent of these funds were “no longer available,” and that “any contested litigation or enforcement action commenced against XTM would put the company into receivership.”
XTM signed a document in February confirming that its total indebtedness to Northland was $2,161,647.07, according to the lawsuit.
Later that month, XTM filed for creditor protection in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. The lawsuit indicates the company has since been sold to Pateno Payments Inc., and its clients—including Northland—have been able to continue using the AnyDay platform.
The relief sought
The civil claim lists Keith McKenzie, Randy Khalaf, Olga Balanovskaya, Michael Li, Jakob Ripshtein and Cary Strange as defendants.
McKenzie is listed as a current director of XTM, Khalaf and Balanovskaya are listed as former directors, and Li, Ripshtein and Strange are listed as former executives of the company.
In their roles as directors, McKenzie, Khalaf and Balanovskaya would have approved XTM’s public statements about the “segregation, restricted use, and protection of client funds,” according to the lawsuit.
Likewise, because of their roles, the executives “knew or ought to have known” about the alleged misrepresentations XTM was making in its public statements.
“The defendants knew or ought to have known that XTM was failing to deal with client funds in accordance with the trust duties and the fiduciary duties, in breach of those duties,” the civil claim reads.
Alternatively, the claim suggests the defendants were “reckless or willfully blind” to XTM’s alleged failure to comply with its duties.
It also alleges that any amounts the defendants received from the deposited funds, whether in the form of cash or other benefits traceable back to the deposited funds, must be returned to Northland under the legal doctrine of “knowing receipt.”
The lawsuit asks the court to declare that the defendants knew or ought to have known that XTM owed trust and fiduciary duties to Northland, that they knowingly assisted XTM in breaching those duties, that they are liable for Northland’s losses and that they are liable for any amounts they knowingly received.
The document asks that the court order restitution for any amounts the defendants received and that they “account for and disgorge all trust property and benefits received by any defendant arising from or traceable to the deposited funds.”
Northland also seeks “general, special, aggravated and punitive damages,” as well as court costs.
Previous lawsuit
Notably, this is not the first lawsuit Northland and its affiliates have filed related to this issue. In February of this year, the same plaintiffs filed a notice of civil claim in B.C. Supreme Court against XTM and its CEO Marilyn Schaffer.
That lawsuit contains many of the same allegations about XTM breaching its duties as a trustee and a fiduciary by comingling Northland’s deposits with those of other clients and failing to have enough money in the account to cover withdrawals to fund employee tips.
The claim seeks much of the same relief sought in the new lawsuit, including findings that the company and Schaffer breached their duties, that Schaffer is liable for knowing receipt of Northland funds or property, and general, special, aggravated and punitive damages.
The earlier filing remains before the court, though online records show no activity on the file since May.
Northland Restaurant Group is part of the broader Northland Group, which owns the Sandman and Sutton Place hotel brands, Grouse Mountain Resort, Revelstoke Mountain Resort, the NHL’s Dallas Stars and a variety of other properties.


