Canada

Death outside closed Vancouver Island emergency room

Updated: 

Published: 

A North Island physician is renewing calls for round-the-clock emergency services, describing the toll the overnight closure is taking on patients.

For some Port Hardy residents, 5 p.m. is not simply the end of the workday. It’s the time their local emergency department closes, leaving them worried about what might happen if they need urgent medical attention overnight.

A death on the grounds of Port Hardy Hospital is bringing renewed scrutiny to the community’s access to emergency care.

“They live in anxiety, and even fear, every night after 5 p.m. when the ER closes,” said Dr. Alex Nataros, a family physician and founder of the North Island Community Health Centre.

“They may be older, have complex chronic diseases, not drive, and may not want to ride the 43 kilometres to Port McNeill, which is a difficult road—icy road—with all sorts of issues,” he said.

Dr. Alex Nataros says patients have described feeling anxious about accessing emergency medical care after 5 p.m.
Dr. Alex Nataros says patients have described feeling anxious about accessing emergency medical care after 5 p.m. Dr. Alex Nataros says patients have described feeling anxious about accessing emergency medical care after 5 p.m.

His comments come after Island Health confirmed a person died following an emergency response on the grounds of Port Hardy Hospital on Nov. 19.

In a statement to CTV News, Island Health acknowledged the tragedy and offered condolences.

“Our thoughts are with this person’s loved ones during this difficult time, as well as the care teams involved in responding to the situation,” the health authority said.

Island Health confirmed that both its care providers and B.C. Emergency Health Services paramedics assisted with the situation.

“We are reviewing the circumstances of this case with B.C. Emergency Health Services, and it would be inappropriate to speculate on any factors that may have contributed while that review is underway,” Island Health said.

The health authority has not confirmed whether the person sought care before the emergency response or whether anyone was denied medical attention.

“What we can say at this time, based on initial review and follow up, is that both Island Health care providers and BCEHS paramedics responded and provided emergency interventions,” the statement said.

Nataros says he does not know the identity of the person who died or all the circumstances surrounding the incident. His understanding comes from a physician colleague who was involved in resuscitation efforts.

According to Nataros, his colleague told him the patient had been outside for an extended period before being brought into the emergency department, well after 5 p.m.

He says his colleague performed an intraosseous procedure, which involves accessing the bone marrow to administer emergency medications when conventional intravenous access cannot be quickly established.

“I understand that the patient died, and that’s the big picture,” Nataros said.

Island Health has not independently confirmed the timeline or the details of the resuscitation described by Nataros.

Port Hardy residents requiring emergency medical attention overnight may need to travel to another community for emergency department services.

‘Three specific patients’ who fear the night

For Nataros, the tragedy has renewed concerns about what he describes as a longstanding gap in emergency services for North Island residents.

He says patients have personally described their fears during medical appointments.

“I can think of three specific patients who told me, in this very exam room, how much anxiety they have every night after 5 p.m. because of their complex chronic diseases, because of their unwillingness to go out of their community,” he said.

“They’ve been utterly and repeatedly failed with basic health-care services for the past four-plus years.”

Nataros says Port Hardy needs a fully operational, 24-hour emergency department, pointing to the community’s health-care needs and the challenges facing people who require urgent medical attention.

He also points to the region’s health challenges, including addiction.

“We’ve had a crisis of deaths of despair in our community, in terms of overdoses and suicides,” he said.

Nataros says he has been advocating for the restoration of 24-hour emergency services since the fall of 2022. He says the emergency department doors have been locking at 5 p.m. since February 2023.

Physicians propose Port Hardy as permanent overnight ER

A statement from local physicians, provided to CTV News by Nataros, outlines a proposal to establish one permanent overnight emergency department serving the entire North Island, with Port Hardy as their recommended location.

The physicians say staffing shortages have contributed to repeated closures and diversions at both hospitals.

“The burden of overnight Emergency coverage has fallen disproportionately on the Port McNeill physician group,” the statement says.

“The stress of closures/diversion has negative consequences on staff morale, which affects staff retention and quality of patient care,” they wrote.

Local physicians are proposing Port Hardy become the permanent overnight emergency department serving the entire North Island, citing staffing challenges and patient-care concerns.
Local physicians are proposing Port Hardy become the permanent overnight emergency department serving the entire North Island, citing staffing challenges and patient-care concerns. Local physicians are proposing Port Hardy become the permanent overnight emergency department serving the entire North Island, citing staffing challenges and patient-care concerns. (Submitted: Dr. Alex Nataros)

Their proposed solution is to designate one hospital as the permanent overnight emergency department for the region, supported by a regional physician call group and consolidated resources, including imaging and laboratory services.

The physicians say Port Hardy is the strongest location, citing its larger population, higher patient visit volumes and greater acuity of B.C. Emergency Health Services calls.

“We believe the best long-term solution is to designate Port Hardy ER as the single overnight ER for the region,” the statement says.

The physicians acknowledge that pending renovations will affect short-term planning but maintain that a permanent regional solution is needed.

Doctor looks to new government for change

With a new provincial government sworn in, Nataros says there is an opportunity to finally address what he describes as years of inadequate emergency services in the North Island.

He is calling on the new Health Minister Ryan Peterson, Premier Lorne Doerkson and North Island MLA Dr. Anna Kindy, who is also Minister of State for Rural Development, to make restoring round-the-clock emergency services in Port Hardy a priority.

Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson shakes hands with fellow MLAs ahead of a swearing-in ceremony in the chamber at legislature in Victoria, on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson shakes hands with fellow MLAs ahead of a swearing-in ceremony in the chamber at legislature in Victoria, on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito

“Today is an opportunity,” Nataros said, pointing to the new cabinet and the appointments of ministers responsible for health and rural issues.

“I am imploring the Minister of Health, the premier and Dr. Anna Kindy to immediately work to get our Port Hardy ER reopened 24/7,” he said.

“It’s been too long that this has been allowed to continue.”

Nataros has been a vocal critic of Island Health’s management of health-care services in the region.

He says his Port Hardy Hospital emergency department privileges were terminated in February 2023 after he publicly criticized Island Health leadership and called for the resignation of its then chief medical officer, Ben Williams.

Nataros also says he was subsequently banned from Island Health property and warned that the RCMP could be called if he returned.

Nataros disputes the circumstances surrounding the decision, saying a complex patient case was used to damage his professional reputation.

Questions remain about overnight emergency care

The circumstances surrounding the Nov. 19 death remain unclear. Island Health says it is reviewing the case with BCEHS but has not provided further details about the emergency response or the overnight care arrangements for Port Hardy residents.

‘They live in anxiety’: Port Hardy doctor renews calls for 24/7 emergency care after hospital death

Questions persist about what happens when someone arrives at the hospital after the emergency department doors are locked, what medical personnel are available overnight and what residents should do if they need emergency assistance.

The physicians’ proposal also raises questions about whether Island Health will consider establishing a permanent regional overnight emergency department in Port Hardy.

For Nataros, the issue comes down to ensuring people can access emergency care in their own community.

“They’ve spent their lives paying taxes, and otherwise, to depend on our health-care system,” he said.

CTV News will continue seeking answers about the circumstances of the death and the future of emergency services in Port Hardy.

‘They live in anxiety’: Port Hardy doctor renews calls for 24/7 emergency care after hospital death