Ontario legislature unanimously passes campaign finance reform bill
Queen's Park in Toronto, Ont. is seen in this undated file photo.
Allison Jones, The Canadian Press
Published Thursday, December 1, 2016 1:39PM EST
Last Updated Thursday, December 1, 2016 5:44PM EST
TORONTO -- Ontario politicians now have one month left to get in a last kick at the fundraising can before they are banned from attending such events.
Legislation that dramatically alters the political fundraising landscape in Ontario unanimously passed Thursday, including banning corporate and union donations and lowering individual donation limits.
Though all parties voted in favour of it, the leaders of the Progressive Conservatives and the NDP were quick to point out that the Liberals introduced the bill in the first place amid a cash-for-access scandal.
The governing party was harshly criticized over fundraising events that saw cabinet ministers attend private, high-priced functions with stakeholders.
Under the new law, which comes into effect Jan. 1, members of provincial parliament, candidates, party leaders, nomination contestants, leadership contestants, chiefs of staff, premier's staff and other party leaders' staff are all banned from attending fundraisers.
Politicians could still, however, attend events where the ticket price only recovers the cost of hosting it, and solicit funds by mail, phone or email.
That strikes NDP Leader Andrea Horwath as a significant loophole.
"You ban MPPs, cabinet ministers, from doing that direct ask, if you will, at a fundraiser...but you don't stop them from picking up the phone and having the exact same conversation," she said.
Attorney General Yasir Naqvi was not able to clearly explain Thursday the difference between soliciting donations in person and over the phone, and why one would be banned but the other accepted.
"Unless you're suggesting that there should be no fundraising and political parties can only fund elections by getting money through public subsidy, that's a whole different question," he said. "Of course, there has to be some mechanism to raise funds. The new world, in my view, what that will look like is smaller donations from large groups of people just like the federal parties do."
When asked if banning politicians from fundraising over the phone was just not enforceable, he said, "I'm not suggesting that, but I'm saying that is a big part of it."
Progressive Conservative Leader Patrick Brown said on the whole it was a good bill bringing much-needed reforms, but banning politicians from fundraisers was overkill.
He will still be hitting up donors at fundraisers for the last few weeks that they're legal, he said.
"I don't apologize for being a worker bee," Brown said.
The Liberals have been posting upcoming fundraisers online in recent months and 17 events are in the next two weeks alone, nine of which advertise a cabinet minister's attendance, including one with the premier for $1,000 a ticket.
Ontario's chief electoral officer has raised concerns about the ban on politicians attending fundraisers, saying his office was not consulted on the rules before they were publicly announced, and it's clear they will require a "significant amount of work" to administer.
And he didn't find any other jurisdictions with similar rules in any other North American jurisdiction.
Under the law, political parties will be given a per-vote subsidy to offset the loss of corporate and union donations. Individuals will be allowed to donate a maximum of $3,600 in an election year, down from $33,250.
Restrictions are also now placed on the amounts that third parties can spend on political advertising during elections and the six-month period before scheduled general election periods, as well as limits to the political advertising spending of registered political parties in the six months before an election.