Ukraine hacks add to worries of cyber conflict with Russia
In this undated handout photo released by Ukrainian Foreign Ministry Press Service, the building of Ukrainian Foreign Ministry is seen during snowfall in Kyiv, Ukraine. Ukrainian officials and media reports say a number of government websites in Ukraine are down after a massive hacking attack. While it is not immediately clear who was behind the attacks, they come amid heightened tensions with Russia and after talks between Moscow and the West failed to yield any significant progress this week. (Ukrainian Foreign Ministry Press Service via AP)
Yuras Karmanau, Frank Bajak, Eric Tucker And Dasha Litvinova, The Associated Press
Published Friday, January 14, 2022 5:46AM EST
Last Updated Friday, January 14, 2022 4:36PM EST
KYIV, Ukraine (AP) - Hackers on Friday temporarily shut down dozens of Ukrainian government websites, causing no major damage but adding to simmering tensions while Russia amasses troops on the Ukrainian border. Separately, in a rare gesture to the U.S. at a time of chilly relations, Russia said it had arrested members of a major ransomware gang that targeted U.S. entities.
The events, though seemingly unrelated, came during a frenetic period of activity as the U.S. publicly accused Moscow of preparing a further invasion of Ukraine and of creating a pretext to do so. They underscored how cybersecurity remains a pivotal concern - that the escalating animosity risks not only actual violence but also damaging digital attacks that could affect Ukraine or even the U.S.
The White House said Friday that President Joe Biden had been briefed on the disruptions, which targeted about 70 websites of national and regional government bodies, but it did not indicate who might be responsible.
But even without any attribution of responsibility, suspicions were cast on Russia, with its history of peppering Ukraine with damaging cyberattacks. Ukraine's Security Service, the SBU, said preliminary results of an investigation indicated involvement of “hacker groups linked to Russia's intelligence services.” It said most of the websites had resumed operations, and that content was not altered and personal data not leaked. The SBU said the culprits “hacked the infrastructure of a commercial company that had access, with administrator privileges, to websites affected by the attack.”
The White House said it was still assessing the impact of the defacements but described it as “limited” so far. It did not immediately comment on a separate, and curious, development - the arrests by Russian intelligence officials of alleged ransomware gang members, an operation Moscow said was done at the request of U.S. authorities.
Russia's past cyber operations against Ukraine include a hack of its voting system before 2014 national elections and of its power grid in 2015 and 2016. In 2017, Russia unleashed one of the most damaging cyberattacks on record with the NotPetya virus, which targeted Ukrainian businesses and caused more than $10 billion in damage globally. Moscow has previously denied involvement in cyberattacks against Ukraine.
Ukrainian cybersecurity professionals, aided by the U.S., have been fortifying the defenses of critical infrastructure ever since. NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said Friday the alliance will continue to provide “strong political and practical support” to Ukraine in light of the cyberattacks.
Experts say Russian President Vladimir Putin could use cyberattacks to destabilize Ukraine and other ex-Soviet countries that wish to join NATO without having to commit troops. Tensions between Ukraine and Russia are high, with Moscow amassing an estimated 100,000 troops near its extensive border with Ukraine.
“If you're trying to use it as a stage and a deterrent to stop people from moving forward with NATO consideration or other things, cyber is perfect,” Tim Conway, a cybersecurity instructor at the SANS Institute, told the AP last week.
The main question for the website defacements is whether they're the work of Russian freelancers or part of a larger state-backed operation, said Oleh Derevianko, a leading private sector expert and founder of the ISSP cybersecurity firm.
A message posted by the hackers in Russian, Ukrainian and Polish claimed Ukrainians' personal data had been placed online and destroyed. It told Ukrainians to “be afraid and expect the worst.” In response, Poland's government noted Russia has a long history of disinformation campaigns and that the Polish in the message was error-ridden and clearly not from a native speaker.
Researchers from the global risk think tank Eurasia Group said the Ukraine defacements don't “necessarily point to an imminent escalation of hostilities by Russia” - they rank low on its ladder of cyber options. They said Friday's attack amounts “to trolling, sending a message that Ukraine could see worse to come.”
The defacements followed a year in which cybersecurity became a top concern because of a Russian-government cyberespionage campaign targeting U.S. government agencies and ransomware attacks launched by Russia-based criminal gangs.
On Friday, Russia's Federal Security Service, or FSB, announced the detention of members of the REvil ransomware gang. The group was behind last year's Fourth of July weekend supply-chain attack targeting the software firm Kaseya, which crippled more than 1,000 businesses and public organizations globally.
The FSB claimed to have dismantled the gang, but REvil effectively disbanded in July. Cybersecurity experts say its members largely moved to other ransomware syndicates. They cast doubt Friday on whether the arrests would significantly affect ransomware gangs, whose activities have only moderately eased after high-profile attacks on critical U.S. infrastructure last year, including the Colonial Pipeline.
The FSB said it raided the homes of 14 group members and seized over 426 million rubles ($5.6 million), including in cryptocurrency, as well as computers, crypto wallets and 20 elite cars “bought with money obtained by criminal means.” All those detained have been charged with “illegal circulation of means of payment,” a criminal offense punishable by up to six years in prison. The suspects weren't named.
According to the FSB, the operation was conducted at the request of U.S. authorities, who had identified the group's leader. It's the first significant public action by Russian authorities since Biden warned Putin last summer that he needed to crack down on ransomware gangs.
Experts said it was too early to know if the arrests signal a major Kremlin crackdown on ransomware criminals - or if they may just have been a piecemeal effort to appease the White House.
“The follow-through on sentencing will send the strongest signal one way or another as to IF there has truly been a change in how tolerant Russia will be in the future to cyber criminals,” Bill Siegel, CEO of the ransomware response firm Coveware, said in an email.
Yelisey Boguslavskiy, research director at Advanced Intelligence, said those arrested are likely low-level affiliates - not the people who ran the ransomware-as-a-service, which disbanded in July. REvil also apparently ripped off some affiliates so it had enemies in the underground, he said.
REvil's attacks crippled tens of thousands of computers worldwide and yielded at least $200 million in ransom payments, Attorney General Merrick Garland said in November when announcing charges against two hackers affiliated with the gang.
Such attacks drew significant attention from law enforcement officials around the world. Hours before the U.S. announced its arrests, European law enforcement officials revealed the results of a months-long, 17-nation operation that yielded the arrests of seven hackers linked to REvil and another ransomware family.
The AP reported last year that U.S. officials, meanwhile, shared a small number of names of suspected ransomware operators with Russian officials, who said they were investigating.
Brett Callow, a ransomware analyst with the cybersecurity firm Emsisoft, said whatever Russia's motivations may be, the arrests would “certainly send shockwaves through the cybercrime community. The gang's former affiliates and business associates will invariably be concerned about the implications.”
Bajak reported from Boston, Litvinova reported from Moscow and Tucker reported from Washington. Catherine Gaschka in Brest, France, and Alan Suderman in Richmond, Virginia, contributed to this report.