Homeless youth unfairly ticketed by police: report
The Canadian Press
Published Thursday, November 10, 2011 11:29PM EST
TORONTO - Homeless youth are getting unfairly ticketed by police in Toronto despite the fact that panhandling and squeegeeing have declined over the past decade, a new report suggests.
"It's a problem in Canada that at its root is because we aren't doing what we should around homelessness, we're not dealing with the source of the problem, we're dealing with the symptom by criminalizing homelessness," co-author Stephen Gaetz, a professor at York University, said in an interview.
His research showed that 29 per cent of street youth surveyed reported panhandling and squeegeeing as their main source of income in 1999, a figure that dropped below three per cent 10 years later.
However, the number of tickets handed out under the Safe Streets Act, which was brought in 11 years ago to address aggressive panhandling and squeegeeing, "increased exponentially" over the past decade, from 710 tickets in 2000 to 15,224 in 2010.
A review of the tickets given out between 2004 and 2010 showed that on average, only 20 per cent were for "aggressive solicitation" while 80 per cent were for "non-aggressive acts of soliciting a captive audience," such as those standing in line at a bank or waiting for public transit.
"This suggests the Safe Streets Act is not being used to police a growth in aggressive panhandling and squeegeeing but rather is part of a broader strategy to criminalize homelessness," the report said.
The authors also found the tickets placed a large financial burden on the homeless because they called for potential fines of up to $500 for a first offence, with an average fee of $60. Many of those who couldn't pay ran the risk of ending up in jail.
"To issue fines to people who live in poverty seems to be a really weird way of dealing with the problem," said Gaetz, noting that about 99 per cent of the tickets went unpaid.
The actual cost to the Toronto Police Service of issuing the tickets was $189,936 in 2009, the report added, and $936,019 over the past 11 years.
That didn't include the cost of processing tickets and amounted to 16,847 hours of police time.
The report made several recommendations, including that the Ontario government repeal the Safe Streets Act and instead invest in more effective strategies to end homelessness.
It also asked that the federal government ensure there are effective discharge plans and supports for all inmates leaving correctional facilities, and that the city of Toronto order a review of police practices in dealing with people who are homeless.
The study, co-authored by Bill O'Grady of the University of Guelph, drew on more than 240 interviews with street youth in Toronto in 2009, as well as a review of official statistics on Ontario Safe Streets Act tickets in Toronto over the past 11 years.