Kim Kardashian a member of America’s First Family?

The notion was a bit too much for people to take.

Cosmopolitan, a magazine geared towards women, tweeted a photo Sunday night of their latest cover. On it, Kim Kardashian flanked by her four sisters – Khloe and Kourtney Kardashian and Kylie and Kendall Jenner – as well as her momager Kris Jenner and the words “America’s First Family” in bold pink print.

America’s official First Family is always considered to be the president, his spouse and their children. But the photo of the reality TV stars marked the first time in four years they had been photographed together and Cosmo chose to highlight the moment as part of their 50th birthday celebration.

The tweet was retweeted more than 300 times but the backlash the magazine received went on for hours. Here are some of the reactions people had to the cover.